Most first interviews test how well a candidate prepares for interviews. They answer the questions everyone expects, tell the stories they have rehearsed and leave both sides with a polite impression and very little information.
For a small consultancy, a coaching practice or an early-stage startup, every hire changes the business. You cannot afford a process that only measures confidence. A better first conversation shows how someone thinks about the work you actually need done.
Bring one real problem
Pick a small, real challenge from your business and talk it through together. It could be a client who keeps postponing decisions, a programme that sells well but renews poorly, or a startup feature that customers ask for and rarely use.
How to choose the problem
- It should be real, recent and safe to share without client names.
- It should have more than one reasonable answer.
- It should be close to the work the person would do in their first six months.
Share the problem in two or three minutes, then let the candidate lead. You will learn more in twenty minutes than from a list of standard questions.

Listen for the questions they ask
Strong candidates ask about customers, numbers and constraints before they offer answers. They want to know who the client is, what has already been tried, what success would look like and what cannot change. Weaker candidates jump straight to a solution.
The quality of someone's questions in the first ten minutes predicts the quality of their work in the first ten months.
Signals worth noting
- Do they clarify the goal before suggesting a fix?
- Do they ask for data, or for an opinion?
- Do they consider the client's point of view, not only the firm's?
- Can they change their mind when you share new information?
Describe the job honestly
Spend the last part of the interview on what the role really involves, including the less glamorous parts: travel, client pressure, admin, the weeks when everything happens at once. A candidate who still wants the job after an honest description is far more likely to stay.
Startups in particular tend to oversell. If the role will change three times in the first year, say so. The right people find that exciting. The wrong people will leave anyway, just later and at a higher cost.
Score right after the call
Write down your scores before you talk to anyone else. It keeps the decision fair and stops the loudest opinion in the room from winning. Use the same four or five criteria for every candidate and a simple scale.

A scorecard that works
- Problem framing: did they understand the real question?
- Curiosity: did they ask useful questions before answering?
- Judgement: were their suggestions practical for a business of our size?
- Communication: could a client follow their thinking?
- Fit with the role: do they want the job as it really is?
Respect the candidate's time
A good process is short and clear. Tell candidates how many steps there are, what each one involves and when they will hear back. Reply to everyone, including the people you do not hire. In a small market, today's candidate is often tomorrow's client, partner or referral source.
Putting it together
- Replace standard questions with one real, anonymised problem.
- Let the candidate lead and pay attention to the questions they ask.
- Describe the role honestly, including the hard parts.
- Score independently before discussing.
- Keep the process short and reply to everyone.
Hiring well is one of the highest-leverage things a founder or partner can do. A better first interview costs nothing extra, and it tells you something you can actually use.

James Wilson
Financial Analyst
James Wilson turns financial data into practical insight. He builds forecasts, models scenarios and reviews investments, giving clients a reliable view of what each option means for growth, cash and long-term value.
View full profile



